A Second Virtual Meeting on LANL’s Proposed Tritium Venting is Planned
Due to the myriad of technical flaws that occurred during the October 20th virtual meeting on the proposed and controversial venting of 114,000 Curies of radioactive tritium from Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL), the Department of Energy (DOE) committed to holding a second virtual meeting. It may be held as early as next Tuesday, October 27th. CCNS will post alerts on our social media network once a date and time has been determined.
Over 150 people attended the virtual meeting. Many people left early due to the uncontrollable feedback and a variety of problems with the powerpoint. The session was recorded. If requested, the session will be translated into Spanish. The PowerPoint and other information are available at https://www.lanl.gov/environment/ , under “Resources.”
Pete Maggiore, a Senior Advisor and Acting DOE Assistant Manager at LANL, hosted the meeting. The meeting was held only to receive public comments and questions. DOE did not provide responses. Maggiore hoped to respond to all comments in writing before the next virtual meeting.
Brian Watkins, a subject matter expert, presented a 14-slide PowerPoint. https://www.lanl.gov/environment/flanged-tritium-waste-containers.php
He described the four Flanged Tritium Waste Containers, called FAT WACS, which are about 51-gallon stainless steel pressure vessels. One FAT WAC can hold four to five smaller containers, called AL-M1s. Watkins said only the gas in the larger container, or the headspace gas, would be vented.
After Watkins’ presentations, those who wanted to speak were given two minutes each. Jay Coghlan, of Nuclear Watch New Mexico, observed that an analysis of alternatives to the venting has not been publicly released and that the New Mexico Environment Department has not seen it. https://nukewatch.org/
Beata Tsosie, Coordinator of Tewa Women United’s Environmental Health and Justice Program, said she does not consent to the continuing desecration of her homelands and ancestral sites. Because there is no safe level of exposure for tritium, Tsosie expressed her concern for pregnant women being exposed to the vented tritium. She suggested that Indigenous and western technology and science come together to figure our how to cleanup LANL’s radioactive, toxic and hazardous waste mess. https://tewawomenunited.org/
Cynthia Naha said that the federal government had not fulfilled its trust responsibilities to the Pueblos as evidenced by the fact that the downstream Pueblos of Cochiti, San Felipe, and Santa Ana had not heard anything about the proposed venting.
Dee Finney, a public health nurse living 20 miles downwind of LANL, expressed concern about emergency preparedness and notification procedures during the pandemic. She asked whether there is an evacuation plan. She also asked to see the analysis of alternatives to venting.
Leona Morgan, a co-founder of the Albuquerque-based Nuclear Issues Study Group, said she does not consent to the venting, which she described as an example of environmental racism. https://www.facebook.com/NuclearIssuesStudyGroup/
Carol Miller, a public health advocate, summarized the feelings of many of the commenters by saying, “We don’t want it.”
Cindy Weehler, a retired chemistry teacher, said that while LANL claims it is a “world class laboratory,” the virtual meeting was operated like the Keystone Cops. She pointed to LANL’s failure in allowing the drums to become pressurized and said the penalty should belong to LANL. She said, “This is your fault, not the public’s. Someone at LANL made a poor decision,” and LANL needs to make decisions now that won’t harm the public.
Joni Arends, of CCNS, asked what plan LANL has for when the international Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons goes into effect. https://www.un.org/disarmament/wmd/nuclear/tpnw/
Forty-seven nation states or countries have signed and ratified the Treaty – only three more are needed for it to go into effect. https://www.icanw.org/
The Treaty was modeled after the Convention on the Prohibition of the Use, Stockpiling, Production and Transfer of Anti-Personnel Mines and on Their Destruction (or Mine Ban Convention) https://www.un.org/disarmament/convarms/landmines/
and the Convention on the Prohibition of the Development, Production, Stockpiling and Use of Chemical Weapons and on Their Destruction https://www.un.org/disarmament/wmd/chemical/ , which challenged countries that still possessed those weapons. Arends asked how LANL would address the economic harm that could occur to the workers, families and communities that have supported LANL once the Treaty goes into effect. She asked again, “What’s the plan?” http://nuclearactive.org/
To submit your comments electronically to LANL, email FTWC_publicinfo@lanl.gov.
Did You Know about These Opportunities to Get Involved?
- Saturday, October 24th – NM Environment Department’s Temporary Authorization (TA) for construction of the new Shaft and underground disposal rooms at the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant (WIPP) expires. Criteria for issuing TAs require that the project be completed within 180 days.
The Department of Energy and WIPP asked for the reissuance of the 180-day temporary authorization. What will NMED do? Violate the procedural due process rights of groups like CCNS who asked for a public hearing about the new shaft? or proceed ahead with DOE/WIPP requests for reissuance of the temporary authorizations for another 180 days? Comments to the NMED Hazardous Waste Bureau Chief Kevin Pierard – Kevin.Pierard@state.nm.us
- Monday, October 26th at 3 pm (virtual public meeting) and 6 pm (virtual public hearing) about the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) draft permit for over 400 sites at LANL with the potential to discharge pollutants during stormwater events. To see the public notice, the draft permit, along with information about registering for the virtual meetings – https://www.epa.gov/nm/lanl-storm-water-individual-permit-draft-permit-no-nm0030759
To register for the public meeting: https://www.epa.gov/nm/forms/registration-form-virtual-public-meeting
To register for the public hearing – which is required by Friday, October 23rd if you want to submit an oral statement and data about the proposed permit: https://www.epa.gov/nm/forms/registration-form-virtual-public-hearing
Public comments due on Monday, November 2nd – see No. 5 below.
- Thursday, October 29th from 6 to 8 pm – Sandia National Laboratory (SNL) and Kirtland Air Force Base (KAFB) Semi-Annual Public Meeting about their environmental programs and the proposed SNL Chemical Waste Landfill Post-Closure Care Permit Renewal. For more information, the meeting agendas and presentations:
- Friday, October 30th – Cold War Patriots 12th National Day of Remembrance – Virtual Ceremony. Register at https://coldwarpatriots.org/
- Monday, November 2nd – public comments due to EPA about two draft discharge permits for LANL under the Clean Water Act National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES). Sample public comments you can use will be available at http://nuclearactive.org/ after the October 26th EPA public meeting and hearing.
- Tuesday, November 3rd – Comments due to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) about the proposed consolidated interim storage facility at Waste Control Specialists/Interim Storage Partners (WCS/ISP) for high-level radioactive waste from nuclear power plants on the TX/NM border, five miles east of Eunice, NM. Information and sample public comments available here: http://nonuclearwasteaqui.org/ , http://www.beyondnuclear.org/radioactive-waste/ , https://www.sierraclub.org/texas/blog/2020/09/high-level-radioactive-waste-dump-could-come-texas , and https://www.nirs.org/campaigns/dont-waste-america/
Tags: AL-M1 containers, alternatives to venting, Beata Tsosie, Brian Watkins, Carol Miller, CCNS, Chemical Weapons Treaty, Cindy Weehler, Cynthia Naha, Dee Finney, Department of Energy (DOE), do not consent, emergency preparedness and notification procedures, environmental racism, evacuation plan, FAT WACS, Flanged Tritium Waste Containers, FTWCs, Jay Coghlan, Joni Arends, Keystone Cops, Landmine Treaty, LANL, Leona Morgan, Los Alamos National Laboratory, Nuclear Issues Study Group, Nuclear Watch New Mexico, Pete Maggiore, powerpoint, pressurized containers, second meeting, second virtual meeting, Tewa Women United, Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons, tritium, venting, world class laboratory, “What’s the plan?”